Potterview #3: Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is where these books start to get really good. It’s darker, it’s more interesting, and we’re starting to leave behind the simple mystery plots and enter into the more complicated ones.

One reason I really like this book is the introduction of Sirius.  I really love Sirius as a character.  To Harry, he is both a good friend and a role model.  Like Harry, Sirius is a rebellious Gryffindor with a love for danger and adventure.  I love how Harry can relate to Sirius because he sees himself in Sirius.

I also really like Lupin as a character.  I like his calm intelligence and his willingness to take Harry under his wing.  He is, of course, discriminated against for being a werewolf, which is a great, subtle way for Rowling to introduce the concept of discrimination in the wizard world.  Wizards, as we see time and again in the books, are very discriminatory and quick to condemn.  Even though it may be detrimental to their children’s educations, the wizard world will not allow a werewolf to teach at Hogwarts.

On the subject of Sirius, this book is where we really see the emphasis Harry puts on his father figures. While sweet, this trope is a bit misogynistic. Throughout the course of the book, Harry strongly prioritizes his male role models. He has several father figures, while the only mother figure I can think of is Molly Weasley. This is probably subconscious on Rowling’s part, since it’s common in our society to prioritize male role models.

Some very dark concepts are played with in this book. The idea of Azkaban is, obviously, terrifying. The dementors, who can suck out all happy feelings and memories, are fantastic antagonists. The fact that Sirius is innocent makes the time he spent there seem even worse. I felt terrible for Sirius for the entire book.

As I reread the series, I am finding that I like Ron a lot less. In this book, especially, he’s horrible to Hermione. Hermione, being very bookish, has probably not had very many friends besides Ron and Harry. Added to that, she’s under a lot of stress from her extra classes. Ron really had no right to turn on her.

Overall, the book was great. On to Goblet of Fire!

Potterview Number 1: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone

I’m going to assume that everyone who likes books enough to follow a book review blog has already read the Harry Potter series. So I’ll be skipping the plot summary and diving right in!

The thing I noticed the most about this book was that it was very markedly a book for children. Most of the story is full of descriptions of Hogwarts, Diagon Alley, and comedic moments with the Dursleys. While it’s very whimsical and fun, the actual plot felt a bit thin.

The climax also felt a bit underwhelming. It was very exciting the first time I read it, of course. And the twist ending was very clever. But considering what I know about the stakes of the climaxes of the other books, it felt small.

On the upside, I loved seeing all the characters again. It felt good to see Harry full of awe and innocence, with no knowledge that within seven years, almost everybody he loved would be dead. Ron was funny, and I loved tiny, bossy Hermione. It was even fun to see Neville try to fight Malfoy, knowing that soon, he would fight Voldemort.

This review is short, but the book didn’t leave much of an impression. I love the whimsy of this book, and the world Rowling has created, and I don’t want to disrespect it. But compared to the others in the series, it was a bit dull and hard to get through. I’m looking forward to the rest of the series, though!